S. M. Stirling’s Against the Tide of Years is another gripping installment in his Nantucket series, but I must warn potential readers—this novel is not for those under seventeen. The story is undeniably compelling, yet it demands a strong stomach and, more importantly, a firmly grounded Christian faith. At one point, I was genuinely tempted to abandon it! My review will hopefully explain why so please continue reading.
This sci-fi epic can be disorienting at times, even with the chapter dates provided. The narrative jumps between timelines, so keeping the plot straight requires careful attention. That said, the world-building is excellent, and Stirling’s meticulous research shines through in the vivid depictions.
Why do I recommend this book only for mature readers with a strong faith? The answer lies in its unflinching portrayal of violence and brutality. While the sexual content fades to black (so it’s not explicit in that sense), the battle scenes and depictions of life in Achaea (modern-day Greece, Northern Macedonia, and parts of western Turkey) are harrowing. Crucifixion, torture, and other graphic elements are woven into the story.
The moment that nearly made me quit? A character dismissing Christianity as a “heresy”—until I recalled that this character was Jewish and held that belief. A jarring but necessary reminder of the story’s historical and cultural depth.
Age Suggestion: 17+
Category: Historical Science Fiction
Review Rating: 4/5
Do you enjoy my honest reviews of books and other products? Would you like to see more? Consider joining the Kingdom, and supporting my reviews and other family-friendly content!
Get Every New Post Right in Your Inbox!
Never miss a weekly article, your favorite gaming videos, Power Up Notes news videos, and quotes/asides. Enter your email below to get notified whenever I post!
We respect your privacy. This list is for post notifications only.